Three references.Each reference must be from a nursing
journal and have at least 1 nurse
author. Each reference is peer reviewed and is
primary research **not a review of
literature** and cannot be more than 5years old.
NURS 115 Article Review Assignment Final Draft Rubric
Element of Final Draft | Max Points Possible | Deductions | Min Points Possible |
Title Page & Abstract
· Title of paper, author’s name, and institutional affiliation formatted according to pp. 23-24 of APA manual (6th Edition). Running head according to APA format · No author note required · Abstract: 150 words or less, summarize in your own words, the main ideas from the three articles. Formatted according to pp. 25-27 of the APA manual. · No keywords are needed on the abstract |
All elements are present and correctly formatted according to the APA manual (6th Edition)
2 points |
Elements are missing or are not correctly formatted according to the APA manual (6th Edition)
1 point |
All elements are absent
0 points |
Introduction
· Describe the purpose of each research study. · Include background information and what is known about this topic. |
All elements are present and correctly formatted according to the APA manual (6th Edition)
2 points |
Elements are missing or are not correctly formatted according to the APA manual (6th Edition)
1 point |
All elements are absent
0 points |
Search Strategy
· Details are provided about how each article was selected. · Must include: search engines, search terms, inclusion/exclusion criteria, and number of articles yielded. |
All elements are present and correctly formatted according to the APA manual (6th Edition)
1 point |
Elements are missing or are not correctly formatted according to the APA manual (6th Edition)
0 points |
|
Research Methods
· Each article is summarized in your own words. · Address how each research was conducted and whether each study is qualitative or quantitative. · Articles are cited according to p. 177 in the APA manual (6th Edition) |
All elements are present and correctly cited according to the APA manual (6th Edition)
5 points |
Elements are missing or are not correctly cited according to the APA manual (6th Edition)
-1 point for each missing element (Maximum 5 point deduction). |
5 or more elements are missing or section is absent
0 points |
Results
· Research findings are discussed for each article. · Study strengths and limitations are described for each study. · Articles are cited according to p. 177 in the APA manual (6th Edition) |
All elements are present and correctly cited according to the APA manual (6th Edition)
5 points |
Elements are missing or are not correctly cited according to the APA manual (6th Edition)
-1 point for each missing element (Maximum 5 point deduction). |
5 or more elements are missing or section is absent
0 points |
Conclusion
· Discuss what changes should be implemented, based on the research, into nursing practice. · Articles are cited according to p. 177 in the APA manual (6th Edition) |
All elements are present and correctly cited according to the APA manual (6th Edition)
5 points |
Elements are missing or are not correctly cited according to the APA manual (6th Edition)
-1 point for each missing element (Maximum 5 point deduction). |
5 or more elements are missing or section is absent
0 points |
Paper Guidelines
· Papers must be written in the 3rd person (no I, me, you, we) · No more than 2 quotes may be used in the entire paper and none may be in the abstract · The following headings are included and formatted according to pp. 62-63 of the APA manual (6th Edition): Search Strategies, Research Methods, Results, and Conclusion · No spelling or grammatical errors noted · Maximum of 5 pages excluding title page, abstract, and References · Entire document is formatted with 12-point font, Times New Roman, margins, and spacing according to pp. 228-229 of the APA manual (6th Edition) · Turn-It-In must be <25%. |
All elements are present and correctly formatted according to the APA manual (6th Edition)
5 points |
Elements are missing, are not correctly formatted according to the APA manual (6th Edition), or there are spelling/grammar errors.
-1 point per each missing element or error (Maximum 5 point deduction). |
5 or more elements are missing, are not correctly formatted according to the APA manual (6th Edition), or spelling/grammar errors are noted
0 points |
References
· Each reference must be from a nursing journal and have at least 1 nurse author. · Each reference is peer reviewed and is primary research **not a review of literature** · Reference page is formatted according to pp. 37, 181, 198-201 the APA manual (6th Edition) · References should be less than 5 years old. |
All elements are present and correctly formatted according to the APA manual (6th Edition)
5 points |
Elements are missing or are not correctly formatted according to the APA manual (6th Edition)
-1 point per each missing element (Maximum 5 point deduction). |
5 or more elements are missing or are not correctly formatted according to the APA manual (6th Edition)
0 points |